Your Right to Fish for Food


|  |
Great
Barrier Marine Reserve Application
Objection
by Auckland City Council
1
October 2004
1 October 2004
Director General of Conservation
Department of Conservation
Auckland Conservancy
Private Bag 68-908
Newton
Auckland City
Dear Mr Logan
RE: AOTEA
(GREAT BARRIER) MARINE RESERVE APPLICATION
Thank you for the
opportunity to make a submission on the Department,s Application for a
marine reserve on the north-east cost of Great Barrier Island.
I note that this application is a continuation of the consultation undertaken
by the Department in March 2003 and I acknowledge that the Department
has broadly addressed many of the issues raised in Auckland City,s previous
submission to the March 2003 Discussion Document.
Auckland City is not able to support the Department,s Aotea Marine Reserve
Application as it has significant reservations and concerns that do need
to be addressed before Council can support the Reserve application. Auckland
City,s reservations and concerns are detailed below.
Relationship to the development of a Strategic Plan for the
Hauraki Gulf
In September 2003 the Hauraki Gulf Forum considered two reports, the
first, prepared by Auckland City, outlined the need to consider strategically
integrating and balancing the protection and use of the Hauraki Gulf,s
marine reserve environment. The second report prepared jointly by the
Department and MFish set out a process for development of a strategic
plan for the Gulf. The Hauraki Gulf Forum adopted the recommendations
in both reports.
Council is seeking a systematic approach to the selection of marine protection
sites based on scientific research using set criteria while balancing
wider social, economic, cultural and environmental considerations. This
approach enables a wider use of protection measures such as the creation
of marine reserves and the application of fishery management tools to
enable site specific protection measures to be applied to particular marine
circumstances.
Auckland City supports the development of an over all plan for the provision
of marine protected areas within the Gulf to ensure:
A more systematic approach is taken to marine site selection;
- The full "tool box", of marine protective mechanisms could
be used to protect the marine resources or habitats while achieving
more appropriate social, economic cultural and environmental outcomes;
- A clear direction and focus is provided for in the future implementation
and management of marine protected areas;
- There was more buy-in from the community in terms of local communities
taking ownership of their local marine protected areas;
- Better integrated management of marine resources and the allocation
of marine space was achieved; and
- The community,s marine protection efforts could then be focused to
those sites selected through the identification process.
In addition, Council notes that the Marine Reserves Bill proposes a range
of marine management tools and the better integration of marine reserves
protection with other existing marine tools and mechanisms.
Auckland City considers that this Bill, together with a strategic plan
for the provision of marine protected areas within the Gulf will provide
a more comprehensive and targeted range of protection mechanisms for the
Hauraki Gulf. In doing so it will create an effective balance between
management and protection of marine environments and community expectations.
In acknowledging that there should be a strategic approach to marine reserve
planning, Auckland City would prefer the Department to postpone its Aotea
Marine Reserve application and to reassess the suitability of the site
once a plan has been developed for marine protected areas within the Hauraki
Gulf.
Commercial Fishing
Auckland City remains extremely concerned about the depletion of fish
stocks and continued degradation of benthic marine environments in the
Hauraki Gulf through the cumulative impact of bulk commercial fishing
practices.
Accordingly Council supports the effects of a marine reserve that excludes
commercial fishing in the proposed reserve area. However, Council remains
concerned about the continuing impacts of commercial fishing within the
wider Hauraki Gulf. Of particular concern is the expected displacement
and intensification of commercial fishing as a result of the reserve to
other parts of the Hauraki Gulf, particularly around the south-eastern
coast of Great Barrier Island.
Auckland City believes the Department has to consider and address the
adverse impact a reserve will have on the rest of the Hauraki Gulf and
work with MFish to ensure that fishery management tools, such as an reduction
in permitted commercial fishery quotas for the Hauraki Gulf is implemented.
This approach is again consistent with Auckland City,s initiative to have
an overall plan for the provision of marine protected areas within the
Hauraki Gulf Marine Park.
Customary and subsistence fishing rights
In Council's previous submission in 2003, we advised that the Department
needed to give further consideration to the social and economic impacts
of the proposed marine reserve on local residents, particularly those
along the north-east coastline.
Auckland City considers it is important to distinguish between recreational
and subsistence/customary fishing. Due to the relative isolation of Great
Barrier Island, its residents rely heavily on fishing to support and supplement
their diet. The Department has acknowledged this in its offer of an exemption
to allow limited fishing in the reserve by the Mabey and Rope Family Trust.
Council strongly supports this approach.
However, Auckland City is aware of several other landowners and residents
in the vicinity of the reserve, including those adjacent to the Whangapoua
Estuary, who also rely on the ability to fish in the area to supplement
their diet and will be materially affected by the reserve. Auckland City
strongly supports the Department making a similar offer to all landowners
and residents that will be affected by the marine reserve.
Council is aware that residents and landowners from other parts of the
Island also need to fish in the proposed reserve area to supplement their
diet from time to time. This is particularly necessary when their fishing
is restricted due to inclement weather in other parts of the Gulf or when
competing with recreational fishers during peak seasons. We consider that
there is a case for the Department to consider granting permitted (limited)
fishing rights to these existing landowners and residents.
Auckland City understands that there are at least two possible mechanisms
under the Marine Reserves Act 1971 that could provide for limited subsistence
and customary fishing by existing residents and landowners of Great Barrier
Island, these are under:
- Section 3(3) which provides for authorisation to fish within
a reserve by notice in the Gazette given by the Minister, having
regard to the purpose of the reserve (S 3(1)), and with provision
for conditions to be attached in relation to the fishing permitted;
and
- Section 3(4), which provides for conditions imposed by an order
in Council made under Section 5 of the Act (establishing a Marine
Reserve.)
Consultation
Auckland City has significant concerns about the extent and appropriateness
of the consultation undertaken by the Department since receipt of submissions
in March 2003. This concern arises, as there appears to be significant
groups, such as tangata whenua and adjacent landowners (as noted above)
who have not been adequately consulted with, and whose legitimate concerns
remain outstanding.
While the Department appears to have undertaken due consultation process
as required by the current Marine Reserves Act, it is of grave concern
that significant affected parties have not been proactively engaged in
discussions to identify options for resolving potential adverse impacts
on the established way of life and means of support for islanders.
Council expects that where residents and landowners are likely to be adversely
affected by the proposal the Department must negotiate appropriate outcomes
with individual landowners.
Eco-tourism and Visitor Industry benefits to the Island
The Council is responsible for providing the strategic direction
for the long-term future of the Great Barrier Island, in accordance with
the Community,s vision for the island. This vision is based around
prosperity generated by an expanded visitor industry catering for active
and passive land and sea based experiences, while being mindful of the
need to maintain the unique character of the island and to provide for
the diverse range of the residents, existing lifestyles.
The proposed marine reserve offers the opportunity to:
- foster appropriate economic growth on the island through expansion
of eco-tourism enterprises;
- strengthen conservation of the natural environment; and
- enhance the sense of community on the island
Establishing Great Barrier Island as an eco-tourism destination provides
the opportunity to find the balance between conservation and development
of a sustainable economy on the island. In doing so Council consider that
it is vital that the economic benefits of enhanced eco-tourism opportunities
on Great Barrier Island are managed in such a way that such benefits and
opportunities flow back to and through the Island community.
Auckland City has particular concerns about how the Department will manage
these opportunities especially in relation to the granting of concessions
to commercial operators to work within the marine reserve. The Department
needs to consider the criteria for granting concessions before a reserve
is established and that the granting of any concessions to operate a commercial
operation in the reserve should provide the local community with decision-making
rights and with a possible right of veto.
The economic benefits that will accrue to the Island through continued
investment and re-investment in the Island (for example the building and
management of hotels/motels) by commercial operators with Department concessions
will be considerable and would in the medium to long term create an economic
base for the island to grow and develop from.
However, there is also potential for negative impacts on the local economy
and social fabric of the island in allowing concession holders to operate
in the reserve without investing in the island or having regard to the
island,s social and economic development. This would be catastrophic and
is inconsistent with the Governments economic growth and social development
goals. Further such an outcome would be in direct conflict with Council,s
strategic direction for the Island and the Gulf.
Importantly if the Eco-tourism benefits are to be realised the management
and granting of marine reserve concessions needs to be integrated with
land conservation areas on the island. This is important as the granting
of concessions giving exclusive rights of control and management of all
or part of the reserve to a private entity has the potential for restricting
public access to a conservation area through charging mechanisms and other
means such as monopolising access points.
The proposed marine reserve would enhance tourism opportunities and if
managed appropriately is consistent with the promotion of Great Barrier
Island as an eco-tourism destination. However, this will require a recognition
that local economic development takes a significant time and is incremental.
Both the Council and the Department will need to work together with the
local community to facilitate and support the development of eco-tourism
opportunities. The Department of Conservation, Auckland City Council and
visitors to the island, will need to support the local economy in simple
ways such as by purchasing goods and services on the island, where practicable.
By working with the local community and encouraging it to have Oownership,
of the marine reserve, there are likely to be benefits to the Department
which include providing assistance with the monitoring of activities within
the reserve, and community promotion and education of the purpose and
benefits of marine reserves.
Recommendations
As stated earlier Auckland City is unable to support the Department,s
Aotea Marine Reserve Application as the application raises significant
concerns for the Council. If the Department is able to address these concerns
then Council is able to support the Reserve application. To assist the
Department Auckland City has a number of recommendations, which will address
it concerns and reservations.
Consultation
- That the Department undertake further consultation with tangata whenua
to discuss the Ngati Rehua Ngati Wai ki Aotea Trust Board,s outstanding
concerns with an expectation that the Department will work constructively
towards an amicable outcome agreeable to both parties.
- That the Department undertake further consultation with all adjoining
landowners and residents, including those adjoining the Whangapoua Estuary,
to the proposed reserve to discuss their concerns, and any practical
means by which these concerns may be over come.
Commercial
Fishing
- That the Department work with MFish to ensure the effects of displaced
commercial fishing in the Hauraki Gulf, resulting from the establishment
of the marine reserve, is managed through a reduction in commercial
fishing quotas for the Hauraki Gulf.
Customary
and Subsistence fishing
- That in recognition of the reliance of Islanders on their ability
to fish in the vicinity of the island in a subsistence manner that the
Department :
- Liaise further with those whose land adjoins the reserve, including
those adjoining the Whangapoua Estuary, and provide an exemption to
fish in the reserve on the same basis as that offered to the Mabey and
Rope Families. With the condition that such exemptions will be extinguished
if land is sold.
- Give consideration to permitting existing landowners and residents
of Great Barrier, including tangata whenua, to fish in the reserve under
a permit system, or other suitable mechanism established by way of a
notice in the Gazette given by the Minister, or a condition on the Order
in Council establishing the marine reserve. Such a permit or other suitable
mechanism could include conditions specifying the location, fishing
methods, catch type and size and number of days allowed in the reserve.
Concessions
- That the Department ensure that decisions regarding the granting of
concessions rest with a local Island Trust to ensure benefits of development
and services flow in to and through the local community. One option
Council is willing to promote is the establishment of an Island Trust
with membership including local community, tangata whenua and Council.
- That the Department, together with Auckland City, good faith in partnering
with the Island community and show leadership in supporting the local
economy, in such simple ways such as through purchase of goods and services
(for example fuel) on the island, where practicable.
Auckland City would like to thank the Department of Conservation for the
opportunity to make a submission on its application for a marine reserve
for Great Barrier Island. We look forward to the Department addressing
our significant concerns and working with the Department to further develop
a strategic approach to the protection and management of the Hauraki Gulf,
and the implementation of a marine reserve.
The MoU developed between our organisations will provide a foundation
for a co-operative and collaborative relationship to ensure the benefits
of a reserve to the natural environment, the local community and to visitors
are realised.
Yours sincerely
Bryan G Taylor
Chief Executive
TOP
|